it depends;
you say you dont go a lot of 1d and 2d, which means the weight of the sticks doesnt matter (it really matters for most people doing integrals).
you are pretty new for diabolo (1 year +-) and you will start getting into integrals in the next few months (thats what happens for most diaboloists)
if you are 100% sure you wont try integrals, get henrys alu, they are nice and stiff.
if you think you will get into integrals soon, get henrys carbons.
you can always order extremes from oddballs.com or other shops, or just learn integrals using alu sticks (some people prefer them for that)
i prefer carbons because they are just pure awesomeness
